Quite the opposite. Ryan traded people past their prime and he has received nothing back. He declined to trade Perkins, Dozier, D. Santana, Suzuki etc after career seasons recently. He traded Span, Revere, Hughes who were under team control and those 3 trades looks like a wash. Traded Liriano, instead of getting a pitching coach to help him (and LHSP was a huge position of need since.) Before he retired the first time, he hanged on players too long. Other than the AJ trade and the Hollins trade (when he received Ortiz; but that should be nullified) he did not get anything really back. In the 90s he traded Erickson, Tapani and Guthrie for Scrubs and Coomer (who also was a scrub in any other team). He traded Aguilera for prospects who did not pan out. He held too long on Mientkiewicz and got nothing back (Justin Jones) while Morneau was ready to play. He traded Todd Walker (and Huskey) for nothing (Todd Sears). Traded Javier Valentin (who was a more than serviceable back up catcher) fro nothing. Matt Lawton for Rick Reed and Kielty for Steward were a wash. People thought that he was a great GM because of the Pierzynski trade and the Santana pickup. The Ortiz release, the Casey Blake release, the Liriano trade, few of the above misguided trades, the dumpster diving free agent pickups, the ill-advised extensions vs. trades after career seasons etc, tell a different story if one sees his career as a GM holistically. And then there is the bottom line of one post-season series win in 21 seasons...