I really think this is a subjective, not objective exercise. The reason the Twins FO looks so bad has nothing to do with their wins. It has to do with the appearance of a plan. The Twins do not appear to have one that is rock solid (a general wait and see what the prospects bring). That being said what the D-Backs and Friars have done is more egregious. They actively abandoned their plans to build up to gamble on a short time period. The Friars completely failed and the D-Backs have as well. The D-Backs had some bad luck, but it was such a stars and scrubs team that even one let down or injury (and looking at Pollock, Grienke, and Miller I'd say they've reached that) was going to make it tough. If the Cubs lost two of their studs, they'd still have enough talent to do well. That's a team that is in a good position to stretch. As for the Marlins, that 2012 trade has netted them nothing better then Hechevarria. That's just awful. While it's not the same FO, they just keep cycling through GM's and Managers. They have no plan to succeed. Personally I think Atlanta has a pretty solid FO. I very much suspect their plan is to build up a cheap and solid pitching core and splurge on FA talent in the 2017 offseason.