Moderator's note: This is a discussion thread about a particular trade, becoming derailed by an extended side topic of Billy Beane's body of work, segueing into a comparison to the Twins' GM, and becoming rancorous as a result. Please start a separate thread if you want to discuss these broader matters. (And just to be clear, tangents themselves are not usually a problem when they continue to relate directly to the topic. Donaldson versus Lawrie defensively, fine. Factors underlying this trade, fine. But, Beane has never lost 90 games, the value of making the postseason versus winning it all... let's stick to the topic.)