While the numbers say Carew > Oliva, I still favor Tony O in a completely subjective ballot. Even though it is the same franchise, the Senators get short-changed - It wouldn't upset me if MLB wanted to celebrate the Senators separately to show some love to Sam Rice, Joe Judge, and Goose Goslin as well as Walter Johnson. My list would be Walter Johnson, Harmon, Kirby, and Tony O (with the admission that Carew had better stats).