Twins Video
Maybe you heard: The 2023 Minnesota Twins offense set the all-time record for most strikeouts in a season. Their hitters turned and walked back to the dugout an astonishing 1,654 times, taking the "boom or bust" model to new heights by also tying for the AL lead in home runs.
It's a style that often worked for them, as the Twins captured a division title and advanced to the second round of the playoffs. But the lineup's unprecedented susceptibility to strikeouts made them highly vulnerable to droughts in run-scoring.
Our worst fears came to fruition in the ALDS. The Twins brought home a 1-1 series and then spiraled into a sea of strikeouts at home, piling up 28 Ks while scoring three runs over 18 innings in Games 3 and 4. Like that, the ride was over.
To some extent, the Twins are strikeout-prone by design, and that's fine. "We're trying to find a way to build the best offense," Derek Falvey said after the season. "That will come with some version of strikeouts, but hopefully some version of getting on base and hitting for power."
With high-K, high-power player types like Matt Wallner, Byron Buxton, Edouard Julien and Ryan Jeffers serving as key parts of their lineup, "some version of strikeouts" is going to be a reality. Still, the Twins will benefit from finding ways to dial back the whiffs elsewhere.
Of the top 12 teams in strikeouts this year, only two (the Twins and Phillies) made the playoffs. Even if the K will inherently be part of Minnesota's offensive DNA going forward, the front office would be wise to counterbalance this trait rather than leaning into it as they did with the Joey Gallo signing.
Swapping out Gallo's presence for one of the following free agent targets, on its own, would make a big impact on the team's overall proneness to strikeouts, helping shift them away from an identity that was overwhelming defined by the whiff in 2023.
Whit Merrifield, LF/2B
Merrifield did strike out 100 times this year, but don't let the triple digits fool you – he compiled strikeouts only because he played so much. As usual, he was very durable and useful to his team, accumulating 592 plate appearances. Merrifield's 17.1 K% was well below the league average, and would have been lowest of any Twins hitter who played 50+ games. He has appeal as a righty bat capable of mixing in at multiple spots.
Jung-hoo Lee, CF
The KBO star is setting his sights on Major League Baseball after a prestigious career in Korea. Contact hitting his Lee's calling card – in 2022 his strikeout rate (5.1%) was the lowest in the league as he batted .349 with a .996 OPS and won MVP. His 2023 season was more of same, albeit cut short by an ankle injury. There's an added element of uncertainty in translating Lee's game from another league to the majors, but it seems fair to say that putting the bat on the ball will be a strength.
Carlos Santana, 1B/DH
Santana is a guy who can hit for power without striking out a ton, which is a combination the Twins would welcome. The veteran switch hitter has long been renowned for his discipline, with a 14.8% career walk rate alongside a 16.8% K-rate. His age (38 next April) means he'll likely be available on a one-year deal, but also increases the concern of steepening decline.
Justin Turner, 1B/3B
Turner's appeal is very similar to Santana's: late-30s veteran who can play first base and hit some home runs without a corresponding avalanche of strikeouts. In fact, Turner's offensive totals with Boston this year (23 homers, 31 doubles, 96 RBIs) were very similar to Santana's (23 homers, 33 doubles, 86 RBIs) and his 17.5% K rate was also nearly identical to Santana's. Turner is a year older but has a more consistently strong offensive track record. Lou Hennessy wrote this morning about Turner's potential for a Nelson Cruz-like impact.
Michael Brantley, LF
One of the best bat-to-ball hitters in the game. Since 2017, Brantley has the fourth-lowest K% (10.8%) among MLB players with 2,000+ PAs. He also has a .305/.364..461 slash line during that span. Brantley is is 36 and has a long history of injuries; he's also not a great fit for the Twins' needs as a LH-hitting corner outfielder. But as a free agent target specifically designed to uproot the team's strikeout-centric culture, few would be better suited.







Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now