Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
  • comments
  • views

40 Man Suggesting Shuffles for Twins

Ted Schwerzler



After the Minnesota Twins signed veteran reliever Hansel Robles to a Major League deal this offseason, their 40-man roster was down to just four openings. Needing significant reinforcements still, it’s a good bet that addition by subtraction could be coming.


By my estimation Derek Falvey and Thad Levine have no less than players yet to acquire, but a more comfortable reality is probably in the ballpark of six. With that in mind, a shortage on 40-man spots becomes a reality, and swinging a deal including a player from that group makes some sense.


As things stand today, with Minnesota having made virtually no moves of any real substance, I’d think they need no less than two infield/utility types, another relief arm, and at least one starting pitcher. You can push the argument for a second starting arm, as well as another reliever, and the designated hitter vacancy still must be filled. That’s anywhere from four to seven fresh faces.


So, what happens next?


There’s been plenty of talk regarding the Twins making a move for a shortstop. In that scenario Jorge Polanco can either become a utility option, or he assumes the role of starting second basemen and Luis Arraez goes into flux. I like Arraez moving around a bit more, though he’s also been noted as a trade chip. Regardless of how it shakes out, there’s two 40-man players currently waiting on standby.


When looking at the arms, it’s hard to see many that won’t fit. Both Ian Gibaut and Brandon Waddell we’re claimed off waivers and are penciled onto the big-league roster as of now. It’s fair to believe one of them could be upgraded, but neither should be looked at as a trade chip. Both top pitching prospects Jhoan Duran and Jordan Balazovic are on the 40-man, so if either are swapped for a veteran asset, that’s one way to create a net-zero addition.


There’s little incentive to outright LaMonte Wade and Gilberto Celestino has had plenty of positive talk the past few months among outfielders. Willians Astudillo isn’t really a catcher despite being included in that grouping, but Ben Rortvedt may not be an ideal leap from Double-A being more of a defense only asset at this point. If there’s a position player not expected to be on the Major League roster that gets included in a trade, I think it’s former first round draft pick Nick Gordon.


Over the course of his pro career Gordon has followed a pretty consistent path in that he’s succeeded the second time through a level. He’s no longer much for prospect status, and he’s not a shortstop anymore either. Gordon won’t bump either Arraez or Polanco off second base, and I don’t know that his bat does enough to be the utility guy. I believe there’s a legitimate big-league player here but have contended for a while it will come in a different organization. Now may be the time.


When the dust settles, I think the most likely position Minnesota trades for is starting pitching. Jake Odorizzi would be a good addition, but they aren’t getting Trevor Bauer and everyone else has their own warts to consider. Plucking from another organization and swapping prospect capital looks like a pretty good fit.


I’d be surprised if we saw just a straightforward addition of four new players and throwing a trade in allows a good opportunity to tweak the 40-man openings.


For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz


Featured Video


Recommended Comments

I can see the Twins getting Musgrove from Pittsburg for prospects. LaMonte Wade and Gordon with a lower level prospect seem like a good start to a deal. I can also see Gordon as the 2nd backup MI next season. He seems to have a close to league average bat. .260-.280 Ave with some doubles and a handful of stolen bases.

Link to comment

Having a 40 man crunch really stinks, but it's a nice problem to have to deal with. At some point, someone has to be removed, no question. It seems to me Waddell and Gibaut are the most likely candidates as signings would be direct replacements for them. They might slip through and kept as AAA options with an invite. IMO, the FO is willing to make a trade if it presents itself. But, IMO, said trade would involve players, most likely, not yet in the 40 man such as Larnach, Enlow and a few others.


We hear rumors lately of a payroll around the proposed $125M mark with some flexibility. There are rumors the Twins are potential buyers. Because of this, and Pohlad stating 2020 stands by itself and the team is not looking to recoup lost revenue, and the fact a wide open window exists that I personally speculate they may yet creep payroll closer to the $135M due to opportunity for competition sake as well as bargains available. But we just don't know.


In an ideal situation, the Twins would bring as many as 7 new or familiar names on board. They need a bat, possibly Cruz, a pair of 10th/11th man utility types, a quality SP and one more reliable BP arm. Ideally, they would bring in an additional BP arm and possible 5th SP on the cheap. But can they possibly accomplish all of that on a $130M-ish budget? Maybe.


Forgetting an extra spot or two on the 40 man for a moment, they would have about $42M to accomplish all of this. Let's just say that the slow market is very real and there won't be a sudden explosion of signings for $ that weren't originally expected. That still leaves a thought process like:


Cruz for $13M

Oddo or Tanaka for $12M, OR, Walker, Kluber, etc, for around $10M.

Hernandez as 10th man for $5-6M.

BP arm for $5-6M

2nd utility player for $1-3M, and there are a TON of options.

2nd decdnt BP arm for $2-3M

5th SP option for $2-4M


Anyway you slice it, that's a lot to add against a $130M payroll and about $40-42M left to spend.


There just isn't a lot of fluff on the 40 man to trade. With the future of the franchise and the sustainability factor, moving Kirilloff or Duran or Balazovic doesn't make sense to me unless it's a really good deal. How much trade value does Rooker or Colina have vs their potential to help and be viable pieces over the next few years?


Glad I'm not in charge. If I were, the Twins would be sitting about $140M next season and the only question would be lopping off a final spot or two on the 40 man.

Link to comment
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Create New...