It seems some of you have misconstrued the message. I certainly wasn't condoning what was said. However, if we're talking about Baseball at the highest level of the profession, its open season to discuss a players ability to handle the mental aspect of the game. It's just as important, if not more, than the physical side of the game. Many players cannot and have not handled playing in major markets like NYC. Why is that? Pressure, scrutiny, fans....all of these factors can weigh on a player who is not mentally up for it. Its absolutely fair game to discuss this. I bet if I dug through post history, many of the same users who flamed me for my comments have probably made some fairly savage comments about a players physical ability.
I stand by the statement that he's mentally soft...and that is no different than saying a player is terrible because he can't hit a curveball. Both have the same outcome.
If you can't handle the game physically or mentally, then you end of up doing something else. The world is littered with ex athletes that couldn't handle the pressure in one way or another.