As has been said many places in this thread, including the one you quoted, how do you know that Mauer didn't ask to be put in the lineup and Molitor simply didn't do it? It's not about not being able to criticize a player, it's about being reasonable about it. You, nor I, have any idea what transpired before the game yesterday. In the end, Molitor is the guy filling out the lineup card. I'm disappointed that Mauer wasn't in the lineup last night too, but it's unreasonable to me to rip Mauer alone. Molitor could simply have gone to Mauer and said, "hey, we need you today." He may have, but we don't know. In the end, Molitor is the one that filled out the lineup card.