Moderator note -- there are some deep disagreements in this thread. That's OK under the TD posting policy.
On the other hand, bickering and personal attacks are forbidden. Please let's all keep that in mind.
These articles are written on a deadline, and the definition of "goat" " seems subjective.
My sense is that even the greatest players can have a "goat" moment.
His raw stuff seems above average, and he had some bad luck in the third inning. I would be inclined to give him one more start in the hope that he can adjust to the show.