If Syndergaard and Scherzer are both "available" come the trade deadline, it would be an interesting debate in regards to which direction to go. What would you do if this is what we would give up for both? A: Syndergaard FA in 2022. Young, cheap. Chance of extending if all goes well. We give up Lewis, Graterol, Gordon. B: Scherzer FA in 2022. 34, but still one of the best in the game. VERY expensive. We give up: Graterol, Rortvedt and Gordon. Washington eats 1/3 of his contract.