The chances of the Twins signing Morneau for next year went down today, not up. People need to stop citing this as a benefit of the trade. The % of salary issue is only if they offer him arbitration, which they were never going to. If he'd stayed, he'd have had to take a deal prior to the arbitration deadline. There was no requirement for that deal to be a % of his salary. The 10/5 issue is valid, but there's nothing stopping Morneau from simply requesting a no-trade clause as part of coming back. It would be hard to blame him and we'd probably agree to it. Bottom-line is that players rarely go back to the team that traded him. Yes it happened with Aggie, but it's rare. If the chances of him being around next year were 20% yesterday, they're 10% now. If we'd gotten any sort of returned, it would be fine. But we got a warm clone of Clete Thomas, so the PR hit, however large it may be, was simply not worth it.