The reasons not to extend Hughes are very similar to the ones that would exist to not have extended Bautista. That was more or less my point. Don't get me wrong, AA hit a home run there, but by logic we've all heard here on TD on many occasions (not necessarily from you), he shouldn't have... Side note, I'm not against an AA signing here. He's not my first choice, but I'd be happy if he was the guy they got.