Well for one his OBP being below .300 this year, and barely above .300 for his career. I'm curious where you pulled 34 HR from? He's never hit that many in any season at any level, including being given the opportunity to mash AAA pitching as a 27 year old. If anything Vargas is highly overrated by a segment of fans. What has he done to be given any sort of permanent role? His slugging numbers are nothing special, he strikes out a good amount, doesn't have a position, and doesn't take walks.