I am not ready to give up on Lewis, the production when he came back up shows there is still talent in there and he has looked good at 1B. I think they should give him one more year unless it is for a proven major league middle of the order bat. That is why I am not in favor of Clemens, I think Lewis is better defensively than Clemens and on offense if he shows his production from when he first came back up is superior as well. I know he has to show it and be more consistent but I would not give up on him.
And I still believe Clemens is better utilized in a utility role playing 3 to 5 days a week. I would really love his bat coming off the bench to pinch hit versus what we have had this year. And the question is still there, has he peaked, none of us knows the answer to that.