And yet, we read all the time that bad teams should take fliers on free agents, and trade them at the deadline. Also, do we have any evidence for this claim? I have never seen any study about this, but one might exist. That said, I don't do this to trade Cruz. I might do it to get a great catcher, and then move Garver to 1B or DH to extend his career. He was a very good minor league hitter, which people seem to be forgetting in most of these thread about him. I argued for a couple years Mauer should move off of catcher, who knows how his last few years go if he doesn't get another concussion (which could still happen outside catcher, but is MUCH less likely).