The only problem is your main justification for using Bartlett is also a justification for using any other player: "Since _________ and _______ are not shortstops of the future, we might as well use _________ to fill the gap." But to your other point, Bartlett could probably out hit Florimon. But ironically with the offense starting hot, Florimons bat is not such a liability. Florimon's glove is good to great, depending on who you ask. Also, Gardy loves Florimon as much as he loves Bartlett, so there's that. either of those two guys could have justifiably started at AAA and no one would have blinked an eye. But here they are.