Are a lot of people calling it a good trade, or like me, are many simply saying it's too early to call it a bad trade? There is a big difference. And no, I personally wouldn't make that trade in reverse. I'd never trade a legit prospect for a reliever, ever. As a whole, I understand the increased value of bullpens, but on an individual level, they are still too inconsistent and unpredictable. With no data, just my impression, you seem to see far more good relief pitchers suddenly fall off a cliff than you do any other position.