The logic for considering Winder a better option than Pagan is twofold.
1) Pagan is arguably the worst reliever in MLB history at giving up homeruns.
2) Winder was fresh.
I doubt if Winder was warming up in the bullpen the collective feeling would be absolute dread like it is with Pagan. But it's pointless to carry this on further. It's a bad loss. Onto the Milwaukee series and hopefully better days ahead.