I'm on the record in this thread as being against the Mauer hate, but your post isn't fair either. I think there are some that boil it down to the homeruns, certainly. But I think you're sticking your head in the sand to dismiss the issues to simply that. With Mauer, there is a certain....persistence....(Arrogance? Stubborness?)....that says he's going to do things his way regardless of the circumstances surrounding him. This goes for how he handled his injuries and the questions about it. If I was a player perceived as quiet, borderline diminutive, I probably wouldn't have stood for the awful way in which the organization portrayed my injury. It made him look soft and....he didn't dispute that, which exacerbated the issue. It goes for his approach at the plate that seems indifferent to his role on the team as a run producer and centerpiece of the lineup. He seems content not driving the ball sometimes. Or even attempting to change his approach so he can. It goes for his body language which never seems to change win or lose or (worst of all) when he fails. He's paid to be the man and yet by his body language he couldn't be any further from that. Personally, I put more stock in his production, consistency, and the amazing successes he's had then these more intangible/questionable matters. But to deny that these things can rub a person the wrong way (and seemingly more often now than ever), isn't being fair to the other side.