It is not a "this winter" problem. This is a three year, ongoing disaster. We could have traded for Gose, signed Aoki, traded for Bourjos, traded for De Aza, or kept Sam Fuld for all I care. Or any of the other many possibilities over three years. I mean, is it really your contention that for the last three years the best plan we could come up with as insurance for Aaron Hicks was Shane Robinson? We have PLANNED for Mastro, Jason Bartlett, and Shane Robinson/Schaefer the last three years behind Hicks. Last year we were saved from ourselves by the good fortune of Fuld being waived, but I find it impossible to believe those were our best options. So yeah, why the heck not give up a prospect that ranks 10-20 in your system for such a vital defensive position?