To try and steer away from baseless speculation, I did mean to comment on this. People are getting caught in the moment that was my personal dealbreaker with Hicks. But let's be honest here, most of the time when our attitudes or impressions shift about a player it takes a dramatic turn at some point. Hicks didn't suddenly become a 4th OF, but he's been on the descent from "1st round pick, top prospect!" status to this for awhile. If it helps, Brian Duensing didn't suddenly turn into a pumpkin either but we all had our moment when we said "alright, enough of this guy", same with Stauffer. Could we have nitpicked that one moment to death and decided it wasn't the "right" moment to have that reaction? Probably, but it doesn't change the overall issue. It's not just this gaffe. Or his weak at bat with the bases loaded. It's the cumulative effect of all those moments.