You're right that the bad economy alone doesn't lose him a race, but it's hardly something for him to run on either. He's also the worst kind of fiscal conservative - the kind that picks and chooses what he wants to be conservative about. He still wants a blank check for defense spending, he only busted the unions that opposed him and not all public unions, he was only too happy to hand money back to corporations over people, and he used his position as governor to bully organizations he disagrees with socially. He's not a fiscal conservative, not in the true sense. Only in the sense that the Republicans and Tea Party want you to believe.