I'm beginning to think this is a prime-parody account. Our current "middle of the pack" farm system would like a word. (#2 MLB, #4 ESPN, #4 Bleacher Report, #7 Fangraphs, #3 Baseball America, #16 USA Today lol,)
I would say you have a point about the farm in 2015-2016 but being the worst team in all of baseball for years will tend to get you that. I'd say that any idiot could get a great farm with high first round picks but then I looked to see the likes of Levi Micheal, Alex Wimmers, Kohl Stewart, Nick Gordon and Tyler Jay etc. Kind of a "paper tiger" farm system if you will. Being ranked due to draft equity is not great. They earned their firing on the basis of first round picks alone.
Farm system rankings being the crapshoot they are, it all comes down to long term results. All-Star games are just about the last possible metric I would use, personally. The mandatory All-Star selection was how many of your list? There are two players in the entire organization that this FO doesn't own completely, they literally threw almost everything in the trash and kept a few choice pieces.
Having taken out the trash, we now have an almost entirely homegrown roster that can absolutely compete for championships and 6 top 100 prospects to boot. You never had that in all of Twins history, certainly not under Smith and Ryan. The turnover and turnaround is exceptionally impressive.
As for payroll, comparing 2015 money to 2024 money is pretty silly. They have roughly the same payroll levels by all actual metrics.
It's easy to be unimpressed if you don't know what to look at. This is a top 5 front office in baseball.
Gleemans 2016 prospect list is in a tidy format for a trip down memory lane. Yikes.