As 4th OFs go, imo, Cave is pretty solid in covering all 3 spots, but I would agree that he's not going to win any gold gloves. Kepler seems to the eye to be, at the least, above average in CF, so he deserves the nod over Cave. I think we get easily spoiled by Buxton's play and incredible range, as he makes it fairly easy on the corner guys to only have to more adequately cover a smaller area of the OF.