Actually he is, he has posted a better OWar then him 2 of the past 3 years, many more home runs, and yes durability does count for a lot as well. In fact Turner has been on a steady decline the last two seasons, and is going to be 32, while Dozier is going to be 29 opening day. Dozier is still in his peak, Turner is entering his decline phase (and actually is already in it IMO)