I'm seeing talk about getting a 2B. I could be wrong, but that feels like too specific a target in my mind for a few reasons;
Clemens at 2B, especially against righties, is pretty solid in my opinion. Plus his defense there was ok/fine. Do I think he is a PLUS PLUS defender there? No. Do I think he can be average there. Yeah probably.
Marek Houston will start the year at AAA, and if there is a regular full season he'll probably debut in May or June right? That's certainly when Culpepper would have debuted in 2026 if not for his glute injury. At that point, if Culpepper is still the best SS, then Houston can take over 2b. If Houston is the best SS, then Culpepper can slide to 2b.
Depth is good, and having Clemens at that point as a utility is a good thing right?
All of this to say, I think the best opportunity to try and add the best middle of the order bat is at 1B. I think they should focus on really getting someone via trade to bring in and stick in the middle of the order.
I'll take a true 1B over any of the players you listed with their WAR from 2024-2026 as well as Clemens. Shoot higher, that's what I'm saying.