I like this angle on the question. I can't say I'm overly enthused about any of the prospects you named, and I hope you are erring on the side of caution in what another team would like to make available, but I'd still want to aim higher than serviceable lefty starters and light hitting middle infielders and 27-year old career minor league relievers and so on. I'd try to add more cash or secondary prospects of my own. It's hard to pry away legitimate high-ceiling prospects via sheer quantity, though. As for the question that launched this thread, I'll go light on the specifics but say that my aim as GM would be to improve the roster flexibility going forward. Not being able to find, for example, a spot on the active roster for Polanco, now that his bat appears ready at (recently turned) age 23, is a symptom of congestion on the 40-man; I would trade either Dozier or Polanco, probably whichever would bring me less (relying on my internal evaluations of course), on the likely notion that other GMs aren't dummies either and they value the same things for roster construction that I do. The Plouffe situation is not urgent because it can be resolved to my satisfaction with a non-tender, so trading him for trash simply isn't enough to offset whatever I get from his performance the rest of this season. And so forth... I don't think Pohald would hire me, though - I view the baseball operations side of the business as a cost center, and I think Pohlad expects his operations guy to focus more on the P&L side. I want a budget under which I choose how to invest for the future, and unspent money in a given season strikes me as a waste. I'm more of an invest for the future guy, and I understand that most businesses in the US focus on a profitable bottom line each and every quarter. So, I would be butting heads with the higher-ups on the most basic principles of running the baseball operations, such as using my cash reserves to trade off the Nolascos to free up roster space. Because, while baseball is obviously a business, it's unlike most businesses you can name in certain important ways. Oh well, next lifetime.