tony&rodney
Old-Timey Member-
Posts
10,778 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
94
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by tony&rodney
-
Have no idea how other people view baseball games but the teams playing now are all good defensively, pitch, and put together good at bats. Ryan Jeffers is a free agent. It doesn't seem like any of these four teams would roster Jeffers. While his bat plays, the glove does not. Bailey was available this summer and Cleveland jumped at the opportunity. Defense matters and nowhere is it more important than catcher. Just to add, there have been numerous balls run down in the outfield, especially in the corners, which were extra base hits if Larnach and Wallner were out there. There is bound to be a fair amount of discussion and argument about the importance of roster expenditures given the disparity of three clubs versus the Dodgers. A majority (according to numerous polls with MLBTRumors being one example) of fans believe that parity is needed in baseball. It seems like it is time to identify that more specifically as "economic parity". Revenues should be more inclusively shared. The arguments made quite often this past summer about mediocrity of teams, divisions, or the American League are off base in my opinion. The balance in MLB by talent is fairly close which accounts for the large number of teams within range of a .500 record. Games are often competitive with many teams playing a number of games that end with score differences of three runs or less. The Guardians spirited play last night turned a close game through seven innings into a big win. My take, from watching way many more games than I ever did in the past, is that competitive balance has never been stronger and that the level of talent in MLB is as high as it has ever been. This can account for the difficulty many players encounter when first entering the major leagues. For those unfamiliar with DeLauter, Turang, Bailey, Vilade, Frelick, Espino, and a host of other players I hope you enjoy the games. These guys are really good baseball players. They pitch, run, hit, field, and play a fundamentally strong game. I'm loving this postseason and hoping the Twins make the 3-6 changes needed to help their roster move towards a positive 2027 season.
-
Yandy Diaz hits the ball hard (115mph) to open the Rays offense. The Rays and Guardians are such fun teams to watch.
-
The future payroll is wide open. The possibilities are many, decisions will need to be made. The Twins have been hesitant in their offseasons but could change those ways. If ownership feels that $150M is possible the options are out there. Moving multiple treasured players creates more payroll room. After July of 2025, any of Ryan, Ober, Kremer, Larnach, Lewis, and Caratini might go. The payroll is less important than identifying the talent that fits and having a plan. We are all waiting for some change.
-
Three Players We Wish We'd Seen More Of In 2026
tony&rodney replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Your assessment is fair. As the Twins move forward there needs to be a recognition that defense matters. Emmanuel Rodriguez is not Andruw Jones but he made nearly ten catches in left field that drop with Larnach out there in very limited playing time. The club needs to roster gloves that turn outs into outs and I'm not sure Roden works unless it is in limited quantities. Perhaps he works as a DH.- 32 replies
-
- mick abel
- alan roden
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Three Players We Wish We'd Seen More Of In 2026
tony&rodney replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
True.- 32 replies
-
- mick abel
- alan roden
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Three Players We Wish We'd Seen More Of In 2026
tony&rodney replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Can you guess why Roden was never used more than one inning at first base since he signed a pro contract? Easy transition? He also was used as a catcher. Maybe Roden can be our backup catcher? Infield is different than outfield. Royce Lewis had never played first base at any level in his life until 2026. There was clearly a learning curve for Lewis but he fields ground balls and scooped throws adequately by any measure, metric or eye test. While I believe the Twins should free Royce Lewis (via a trade) to give him an opportunity for a fresh start somewhere else, he did better at first base than the other options last year. Clemens was more comfortable moving to cutoffs and fielding but not very good at receiving throws. It would be wonderful if Alan Roden could magically fill the first base spot but he is nearly as likely to fill a backup catcher position. I'm not betting on either. Roden definitely fits as a 4th/5th OF or DH/PH spot if the Twins choose that route. Injuries happen and we can all be nervous about Buxton, Rodriguez, and Jenkins due to their histories.- 32 replies
-
- mick abel
- alan roden
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Three Players We Wish We'd Seen More Of In 2026
tony&rodney replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Not sure what you are saying here. Vlad? Roden at first base?- 32 replies
-
- mick abel
- alan roden
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
There is a similarity between all four teams - they each use multiple means to acquire players and are strong at developing those players. The Dodgers have a very good scouting and development system as well as a strong minor league organization. They would undoubtedly be a winning club under any system. When you suggest changing the system, are you looking to limit player salaries? I have no problem with that in the big picture but would suggest it be for all including the owners, if that is the direction. No team puts on a schedule of games without other teams to play. Thus the simplest answer is full revenue sharing of all media and stadium income. The reality will be something else.
-
Three Players We Wish We'd Seen More Of In 2026
tony&rodney replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Any way a person spins it, the July 2025 trade deadline moves were confusing given the lack of further moves, either at that time or in October or November of 2025. So that is all in the past and should just remain a loud wtf. Mick Abel and Emmanuel Rodriguez are incredibly important to any odds of the 2027 Twins finding wins. Both players have promise, are inexperienced, and have missed time due to injuries. We want their best and we want it now. Alan Roden had some fun games in September for the Twins. He seems like a player that people find easy to support. Where will he play? His defense is not adequate in the outfield. He looks like a DH out there, but he is much better than Wallner if we want to be kind. There have been many suggestions that Roden play first base. He has played exactly one inning at first base (A+ ball, 2023) in the minor leagues. There is no chance that the Toronto organization just never considered trying to see if Roden could field ground balls or scoop throws from infielders. All teams work players at multiple positions to see where they might best fit and/or help their club. Every organization does this and in a more limited time period so do high school coaches. This (just put a guy at first base) is the same discussion that has occured with Trevor Larnach and Matt Wallner. Slow reactions in the outfield and cautious approaches on hard hit base hits out there don't suddenly become quickness and sure hands in the infield. This is also why Luke Keaschall should never be shuttled back into the infield too. So, what can the Twins do with Alan Roden? It will be interesting to watch. I hope Roden has a fantastic year.- 32 replies
-
- mick abel
- alan roden
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
How Can Eduardo Tait Regain Top-100 Prospect Status?
tony&rodney replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Minor League Talk
Absolutely not. Winning teams all prioritize good defensive catchers. Blocking is way underrated. The Brewers, Rays, and Guardians all play small ball quite a bit. The Dodgers have leaned heavily on Smith to catch and lead the pitching staff. When Smith went down the Dodgers picked up guys who were glove first. It is entirely possible that the Twins kept Ryan Jeffers because none of the offers returned anything worth talking about. We do know that we don't know about the discussions. Defense matters and it all starts with the guys who catch the ball the pitchers throw. -
Twins looking at Logan Gilbert?
tony&rodney replied to Bangkok Twins Fan's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
If you haven't seen a number of mindless trade suggestions yet, prepare yourself. People looking for clicks are already churning out a host of trade ideas. Some are crazy and others are fun. The writers know about as much as any fan does. Organizations don't randomly tell people who they are trading and what they want in return. Elly De La Cruz is in rumors, a few with Seattle. We can put together rumors too. They just get criticized and die on this site. How would folks feel about trading Brooks Lee, Kody Clemens, Victor Caratini, and either Riley Quick or Kendry Rojas for Elly De La Cruz? As far as Logan Gilbert, I was pushing a ridiculous offer of E. Julien and R. Lewis for Gilbert after the 2023 season. This stuff is just for laughs and giggles. Jose Ramirez is clutch. Gavin Williams and Cade Smith are total studs. The Cleveland-Chicago series was so much fun. I'm hoping Milwaukee defeats Los Angeles simply because I enjoy their type of baseball, not because I have any dislike of the Dodgers. The Dodgers play very fundamentally sound baseball and their vets like Betts, Freeman, Muncy, and Smith are so calm in the playoffs. -
Taj Bradley Is Just Scratching the Surface
tony&rodney replied to Sam Caulder's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
The challenge for Taj Bradley has always been about command. In 2026, Bradley was very good on the whole because his command was pretty good across the season. Consistency made his season. The challenges never stop for athletes and Taj will need to prove that he can remain consistent in 2027. That is a batter to batter, inning to inning, and game to game struggle. Bradley has the stuff and he looks like he is a supremely conditioned athlete. No doubt the guy works hard. Twins fans can only hope that the mental challenges are met. Baseball is tough. Every starting pitcher has bad days. In July of 2025, Taj Bradley was toiling in AAA. Today he is the best starting pitcher on his team. The guy has a bright future. Like other young successful players before him, Taj will need to prove himself one pitch at a time. -
Well, this time France would cost 2/$20M at a minimum with an option. But I don't see it.
- 37 replies
-
- ty france
- luis arraez
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Arraez was a really good story when he arrived with the Twins. The metrics police have given him some love recently, which may or may not be legitimate. He was fun to watch. I'm ok if that occurs but want something better for defense, running, and scoring runs. Ty France is a professional and puts together good at bats and competes on every play in the field. I doubt he wants to return to Minnesota but I like his play.
- 37 replies
-
- ty france
- luis arraez
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Ryan Jeffers Open to Twins Reunion
tony&rodney replied to Cody Christie's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Let Jeffers go. The Twins need to embrace a move to athleticism and defense. Kody Clemens had a good year. It was unexpected by all. He is decent in right field, but the Twins can do better at first and second base defensively. I'm not sure the Twins can convince Brandon Lowe to sign or complete a trade for Michael Busch but both are solid gains if completed. Clemens would make a spectacular utility player who finishes the year with 500 plate appearances. Jeffers returns a draft choice or if the Twins are nervous they just let him go. The Twins should be open to moving players. -
How Can Eduardo Tait Regain Top-100 Prospect Status?
tony&rodney replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Minor League Talk
Why does it seem like Falvey was coerced into a trade by the Phillies GM? The ask was Painter plus and the next thing you know ..... There is a probable future for Mick Abel. I like the kid and would just stick him as the #4 starting pitcher next year if he is fully healthy and ready for action. Those July 2025 trades were pretty much well outside of any previous pattern, and seemed rushed. Having watched Tait about 30 times this past summer, it seems like he could be a decent DH. He takes a big hack and has a boatload of power. Catcher? Don't see it. Carson Tinney has the same power and the same arm and is not likely to be a defensive-minded catcher, but he looks like a better bet than Tait. However, as others have pointed out, there is still time for development. -
Witt Jr. plays shortstop for the Kansas City Royals. It's possible that folks can overlook his talents. Think of Bobby Baseball as a Byron Buxton at his peak in full health, who plays the best shortstop in baseball and is healthy enough to average 154 games every year for his first five years. Marek Houston is a promising player and it would possible to hope he wins a job in Spring Training if Houston has a strong offseason of work on strength, speed, and agility while continuing to hone his eye and swing. Nevertheless, we should not place the expectations of a Bobby Witt Jr. on Houston any more than expecting Walker Jenkins to be Ken Griffey Jr. Let these guys develop and play to their talents.
-
From tony&rodney.... AI is correct about 80-90% of the time and Google is about the same. 100% = When a MLB club agrees to go to arbitration with a player, they have signed a contract. The amount is either settled by each side in discussions or the arbiter assigns a value, choosing one of the figures from the numbers submitted by the player and the club.
- 62 replies
-
- royce lewis
- trevor larnach
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Watched quite a few minor league games this summer. Houston improved throughout the summer and was a totally more confident player than he was in 2025. The Twins should bring him to Spring Training and see what he has. Maybe Houston gets stronger and even more athletic over the winter. Definitely a player to watch.
-
Silly. This is a Twins site. You are on here all the time. You are a Twins fan too. Same, same. I have followed Lawlar from early on. He was hot stuff in Dallas. I have seen him play many times. His athleticism is my interest. Arizona has seemingly cooled on him. You don't agree but Lawlar was sent down when the team needed a spark and was never left to play for weeks in a row. I suggested that the Twins should offer Larnach, Roden, and Sands. Biased? I was called names for suggesting that the Twins should trade Lewis after the 2023 season when his value was sky high. Reality? You are maybe too young or cannot remember that the Twins were criticized for trading an All Star catcher for a minor league starting pitcher and a relief pitcher recently converted from shortstop to reliever. Sometimes stuff works, sometimes it doesn't. Enough. Make your own suggestions.
-
We clearly disagree. While Brooks Lee is not an All Star, he is a top ten third baseman in MLB. Jordan Lawlar is a bench player and he might become better. We can also say the same thing about Lee and I'm not high on Lee. As of today there is no comparison due to a host of factors: positions, experience, and reliability. Lawlar has been pushed aside to some extent by Ryan Waldschmidt. Lawlar has some similarity in his initial high prospect value, injury history, and fall from grace as Austin Martin. Roden is not a non tender and he is one of the players I put forth, along with Larnach and Sands for Lawlar. These are basically change of scenery moves. None of Larnach, Sands, Roden, or Lawlar are critical to their teams for 2027. Roden has had the least amount of time to prove himself and there are some people high on him. Henry Davis would be a decent backup catcher. I'm not sure Lewis has lost that much value. I'm wanting the Twins to spend or trade for a first or second base guy. The free agents are not spectacular but Jake Bauers, Ty France, and Brandon Lowe give a team professional plate appearances. The main point is that there are options. I fail to see anything wrong with suggestions and people were always shocked to see values placed on players by the BTValue site. Every year there are a number of trades completed that are greeted with raucous comments.
-
Did you just compare a player with 244 plate appearances over the last three years that has never been a regular player for his team to another player with 1343 PA over the last three years? Like I previously stated - there may be an interest. Players like Larnach, Roden, and Ober have some value. It is up to Zoll to find a way to rework the roster. Rolling it back won't work. We are all just hacks at this even if a few of us know a number of people working within MLB. Put your ideas out there.
-
Seems to me that a ton of the articles and many comments do make suggestions and guesses of some sort or another. The other comments are all negative and complaining about everything from payroll to eye black to perceived efforts. You may be correct about my Lawlar ideas. Arizona does need a LF, 1B, and DH. All teams need pitching. They have specifically published/stated a desire for a LH bat. Larnach and Roden fit that criteria. Lawlar has seen his services squeezed in Arizona. The Twins could use a RH bench bat who can run and play defense. In some ways Lawlar has lost favor similar to our guy, Royce Lewis. FWIW, the list of trades that don't seem to make sense is quite lengthy. Maybe think of some ideas yourself and put them out there. I won't clap back.
-
When a team agrees to go to arbitration they have agreed to a contract. Clubs may sign the player before a hearing and a player may be traded but the contract is done, except for the amount, once the team makes the decision to go to arbitration.
- 62 replies
-
- royce lewis
- trevor larnach
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:

