Great article Nick... You have hit the nail on the head.
Although... The strategy that you refer to as sensible is not.
33 Million spent on vets sounds like something you can put on a brochure with smiling faces on the cover to sell your organization but the reality is that they spent 33 million on an innings eater (if healthy) and part time players who become full time players when the injuries hit.
33 million on part time players! While cutting 31 million off the payroll. This strategy is never sensible.
Farmer and Margot are here to hit left handers. We didn't pay them to hit right handers because if we did that would be hard to justify.
Farmer has 1206 Career AB's vs RH with an OPS of .653
Margot has 1939 Career AB's vs RH with an OPS of .659
They hit left handers!!! These are not the players you roster to hit right handers. You roster them to face left handers and you need to roster players to hit left handers if you are committed to making sure Kirilloff, Julien and Wallner don't have to face left handers which occurs 25% of the time.
This is a sensible strategy only if players don't get hurt. Once players start getting hurt and become unavailable or even if players stay healthy but are not good like Wallner has been... they have to face right handers and they have shown over 3000 AB's that they shouldn't be doing that.
They were so focused on protecting our young left handed hitters against left handed pitchers 25% of the time that they compromised our ability to hit right handers who throw 75% of the time and we paid money we don't have to do it.
Injury is not an excuse. Injuries were always going to happen. Injuries are going to happen to every single team. Once we get our injured 3 back... there will be others to replace them on the disabled list.
We took a major league switch hitter in Polanco and shed him so we could spend that money on multiple lesser players.
Those lesser players are killing us and they will not be released so they will kill us all year.
Santana hasn't been what he was a long time ago for quite some time, DeSclafini was just another innings eater.
Santana, Margot, Farmer and Vazquez will not be waived. They will be around to kill us all year. If we are to turn this thing around. Those 4 will have to turn it around and I'm doubtful that they will.
Bad strategy... Bad Bad Strategy.