Okay, I'm not even going to use fancy stats to show how wrong this is. Here are the basics: Trevor May, the June before he was removed from the rotation: 5 GS, 24.1 IP, 3.70 ERA, 24 K Mike Pelfrey, the June before May was removed from the rotation: 6 GS, 35.1 IP, 5.35 ERA, 16 K Mike Pelfrey, the July after May was removed from the rotation: 4 GS, 23.0 IP, 4.30 ERA, 11 K Mike Pelfrey wasn't better before May was removed from the rotation and he wasn't better after May was removed from the rotation. Mike Pelfrey is who he is. He's a middling starter who can't miss bats and was playing way over his head early in the season. That's great, you let that guy play way over his head and appreciate the effort he gives you. But in the back of your mind, you always remember that he's playing way over his head and you prepare for the inevitable. The moment he starts scuffling, you take his job away, thank him for his service, and move on. Instead, the Twins removed a young starter who was showing consistent improvement, relegated him to the bullpen, and kept that middling starter over him in the rotation.