I considered that but it doesn't really matter when you check the stats. Here is Santana's 2011-2014 line. I added 2011 because he looks really bad without that extra season (he had several on-again, off-again seasons during that stretch): 2011-2014: 126 games, 99 ERA+, 4.19 FIP, 2.7 BB/9, 7.2 K/9 Almost identical to his career line. And by "almost identical", I mean "almost identical". If you take out his pre-age 25 seasons, the numbers nudge up a small amount (102 ERA+) but still miles below what he has done with the Twins.