Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    Working Through Ambiguity: Evaluating the Louis Varland Trade

    We break down Kendry Rojas and Alan Roden, acquired by the Twins in the trade that sent Louis Varland to Toronto

    Jamie Cameron
    Image courtesy of © Bruce Kluckhohn-Imagn Images

    Twins Video

    What a mess. It’s been a few days since the Twins decided to commit ritualistic sacrifice on their entire bullpen. I’m not sure that I have any more clarity on how to square that as a whole. What has gnawed at me since Thursday is a lack of coherence between some of the trades made. A lack of coherence on which light is starting to be shed.

    If the Twins had stopped trading players away prior to the Griffin Jax and Louie Varland deals, there’s a good chance fans view the deadline in a different light. In that reality, you have two high-leverage arms around which to build your future bullpen. It’s also a more explicit statement of intent around competing in 2026, one that makes acquiring Taj Bradley and Alan Roden more palatable.

    That’s not what the Twins did, though. They traded Griffin Jax to Tampa Bay for Taj Bradley in a puzzling one-for-one swap, adding to their stable of almost-very-good young MLB starting pitchers. Varland was flipped to the Blue Jays in a stunner for outfielder Alan Roden and left-handed pitching prospect Kendry Rojas.

    This is a trade of tensions for me. For some, trading a hometown kid made good, under team control until 2030 hurt. For others, trading a former 15th round pick who came to the organization throwing 90 mph and left touching 100 mph was the source of the regret. Both of those feelings resonate with me on some level. I also think the Twins got good value.

    The front office has been criticized for not being cold and calculating enough during their tenure. Whether that was sticking with veteran players when younger ones deserved more playing time, or not catalyzing even moderate turnover of a stagnant hitting core. That’s why this trade felt tough. We went from no change, to all the change.

    I believe bullpen arms are volatile and expendable. I believe you should trade them at peak value. I don’t believe bullpen arms are expendable to the point you should trade them all at once. Even today, we are learning that Griffin Jax requested a trade. I’m guessing more revelations are afoot. This won’t be a defense of the organization's approach at the trade deadline. Rather, a simple appraisal of the value that Varland returned.

    Let’s start with Kendry Rojas, who will make his debut in the Twins organization starting for the Saints on Thursday. Rojas signed with the Blue Jays out of Cuba in 2020 for $215,000, and has enjoyed a convergence of improving stuff and excellent results at each stop on his minor league tour to date.

    22-years old and listed at 6’2, 190 pounds, Rojas has a lean frame with some projection left. It’s a clean, repeatable delivery with some moderate crossfire in his stride. Rojas has a longer arm stroke and keeps the ball hidden well behind his head, adding to some deception in his delivery. In 41 2/3 innings of work in Toronto’s system in 2025, he’s managed a 3.46 ERA (2.45 FIP), struck out 37.1% of hitters, walked just 5.4%, and maintained a ground ball rate north of 51%. That’s extremely impressive production.

    If we want to crudely compare Rojas with Mick Abel, you’re getting more strikes and consistency with the former, more explosive stuff with the latter. But what of Rojas’ stuff? What might the Twins focus on with him?

    It’s currently a sinker/slider dominant profile (yes, the Twins seem to be leaning into that more and more), with a more sparsely used four seam fastball and changeup to round out a four-pitch mix. Both varieties of Rojas’ fastball sit 94 mph but will touch 96 mph. Rojas’ changeup is thrown hard, around 87 mph. It generates some cut and plenty of swing and miss, although there’s likely room for more velocity separation between his fastball and changeup. Finally, the power slider, which averages 87 mph doesn’t have a ton of depth to it and results in ground balls more than swing and miss.

    That’s a really strong platform on which to build. I can see the Twins adding a tick or two more to Rojas’ fastball, tweaking the shape of his slider, and even toying with adding an additional pitch prior to 2026. I’d expect him to get plenty of run at Triple-A throughout the remainder of this season. He’s a borderline Top 100 type prospect for me, with the upside of a mid-rotation starter who should get a look in the majors in 2026.

    Alan Roden, from a bird's eye view, seems like a weird fit. The Twins now have Matt Wallner, Trevor Larnach, Roden, James Outman, and DaShawn Keirsey Jr. as left-handed hitting outfield options in, or close to the majors. My bet would be that this portion of the acquisition makes more sense after the bookend of offseason roster moves which result in a couple of the aforementioned names no longer being in the organization. 

    Roden was Toronto’s third round pick in 2022 out of Creighton, and does a lot of things well. In three minor-league seasons in Toronto’s system, he’s managed a wRC+ of 151 (2023), 138 (2024), and 150 (2025). In 125 games between AA and AAA in 2024, he walked 12.1% of the time and struck out just 14.2% with a .388 wOBA. He gets on base, and he can hit. 

    There are supplementary tools here too. Roden has a good arm (86th percentile arm strength) and is likely around an average defender (which makes him better than both Wallner and Larnach). There’s also above average speed (66th percentile). While you’re not getting slug, you’re getting a little bit of everything else. If Roden is a productive major league starter, there’s plenty of value there.

    This value is, of course, dependent on the Twins being right. I think anyone can be forgiven for not feeling confident about that right now. While the Varland trade was a shocker given the context, the return of an everyday player and a back end starter is the type of value I expected to recoup in other deadline deals (Brock Stewart cough). For me, it’s a trade where I can see the logic in the value, if not the logic in the timing.

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    1 hour ago, bunsen82 said:

    Varland was the local kid who had made good.

    I, frankly, don't care about that at all. But I'm a local kid that left so that makes sense. 

    But even so, I basically think his upside is the other Minnesotan Glen Perkins. Which is a good nice career. Something he should be really proud of, obviously, but ultimately for naught. He was a darn good relief pitcher on really bad teams. If given the chance, the Twins would have been foolish not to go back in time and trade him in 2011 for two of another organization's top ten prospects and try to bet on some actual upside. 

    I expect Roden to be about 6 WAR over the next 3-4 seasons and Rojas to be anywhere from a -2 to +10 WAR player over that same period. It's a good gamble for someone that is, at the end of the day, a good relief pitcher. 

    I am more optimistic on Roden than most anyone else here, but that's only to say I think he is a step or two above Martin due to the fact that he has shown SOME power and has shown SOME defensive competency in the OF. 

    Rojas seems like he must be Rule 5 eligible, explaining why Toronto was more willing to trade him away. Easy enough for the Twins to keep him on there all next season with no expectation he'd get a call-up. Seems he should start the season in AAA and maybe he eventually makes it up. Any maybe he's even someone, especially with that youth and the fact that he's not ever lasted a long season, that is best suited for the Crochet career path: coming into the bullpen initially with the plans of stretching him out as he gains strength and experience. 

    2026 will be filled with patchwork solutions, and if things break right they can compete, but the Twins really shouldn't force players up just because there's a hole. Make sure they've proven themselves worthy. 

    "Current" 2027 Depth Chart - 

    C: ?, ? 

    IF: Royce, Culpepper, Keaschall, ?, Lee, Eeles

    OF: Buxton, Jenkins, Rodriguez, Roden, Mendez 

    DH: Wallner, Gonzalez

    SP: Ryan, Lopez, Matthews, Bradley, Festa, Ober, Abel, Rojas, Woods Richardson, Gallagher, Prielipp

    RP: whatever failed starters the Twins decide, truly no one should be overly concerned

    So the catching is a huge question mark, and the IF is looking iffy. There's enough depth in the OF and the top prospects being exciting enough that I think it will be fine and the pitching looks deep. 


    I have a dream.

    Nothing this front office does surprises me anymore.
    Trading Varland was just another one to add to the list.
    Next up: Ryan and López.
    The roster will be ground to dust, the rebuild will drag for 5–6 years, and Target Field will be a dust bowl. 

    But then…
    Louie Varland re-signs with the Twins after 2030.
    And in 2031, with a rebuilt roster and Louie as the closer,
    the Twins finally win the World Series.

    It only took burning it all down to make it happen.
     

    The Varland trade was eckstrah spechul stooooooopid. Hometown boy with live arm, under control until the end of the decade, his ceiling completely unknown since he starting throwing shortarm. It's quite possible whoever gets him will switch him right back to a full windup, and wind up with a good starter. 

    What did they get in return? Light hitting, average outfielder, and a lefty prospect, possibly decent. 

    Stoooooooooooooopid.

    varland would have been much more valuable with successful closing experience. He would have surely gotten that chance for the remainder of this year and next. If we still stink next yr trade him then. There is no difference between 5 yrs of control or 4yrs. There was no need to trade him now. Build the value. 

    The context of the Varland trade, by itself, isn't the issue, IMO. BUT, the context of ALL the trades together makes this a misfire, along with a couple other moves made.

    But to make this any other points clear, I have to digress some.

    Correa heard about an initial inquiry that was laughable. THEN, the Astro's OWNER bypasses Falvey AND Joe Pohlad and speaks to Jim Pohlad directly. (Who's running this mess)?! Falvey tells Correa, honestly, "You didn't sign up for this". Correa then states that while he wants to stay, he would waive his no trade clause for Houston and nobody else. Correa then speaks to Jax about an impending firesale, and his possibly/probably moving back to Houston and Jax asks for a trade.

    ALL of that is IMPORTANT context.

    1] Jax did NOT HAVE to be traded at the last minute for Taj Bradley. While Bradley has a good arm, the Rays haven't been able to fully develop him as of yet. Maybe the Twins will. Or maybe he turns in to a really good RP. But almost every thing I've read says the Twins undersold on Jax, who would have been the Twins closer in 2026.

    2] While Stewart says his arm feels better than it has in years following his last procedure, it's still possible it self destructs again in the near future. But his arm is talented, has been performing very well, and all of him is inexpensive and cost controlled for the next few years. That means he's very good and cheap. And we move him for a 28yo OF who had ONE good season in 2023? We're going to "fix" Outman when we haven't been able to fix some of our own players?

    3] While Varland being a local boy is a great story, IDK in the context of roster building and value. He's made a tremendous transition to the pen, is inexpensive and cost controlled for the next few years. Sound familiar?

    To be completely fair to Roden, he's younger than Larnach, has more speed, and is a better OF defensively.  Also to be fair, he has a little over 100 ML PA. So we still don't know if his bat will or won't translate to MLB. But we DO KNOW that Larnach is a solid, decent ML bat already. We also know that Rodrigez and Jenkins are 2 of our best prospects, also LH bats, and both relatively close to appearing for the Twins.

    Rojas MIGHT be a really talented LH arm. And maybe he's the real prize here. And maybe he turns out to be a quality SP in some capacity. Maybe he becomes a really strong LHRP for the late innings. And if so, there's real value in that! 

    But COLLECTIVELY, the Twins COULD have had the 2026 bullpen start with Jax, Varland, and Stewart, with hope that Sands settles in closer to his 2024 season. 

    That makes sense to me with all of the other trades that took place. But in the overall CONTEXT of the trades, they moved Stewart for NOTHING. And at the last minute they traded BOTH Jax AND Varland for an OF that is currently redundant in the scheme of things, a talented young RH arm that is trending downward and might end up in the pen, and a talented young  LH arm that has yet to throw more than 84 IP in any MILB season, and also might be targeted for the pen.

    And if and when Bradley, potentially, move to the pen, there is real value in that still. And I'm NOT saying either, or both, might not be solid SP options still. But neither arm projects as well as Abel right now, or Matthews, Festa, or SWR. As of NOW.

    So the pen is decimated when we could have had a handful of 3-4 pieces to build around. And we have a questionable fit in a LH OF, and a couple arms with potential, vs proven quality.

    Once again, CONTEXT is what I'm looking at. Getting more arms is never a bad thing. But the biggest need is to add some actual ML quality BATS. And so far, we have the potentially questionable fit of Roden, and a highly rated young catching prospect, and a flash in the pan 28yo LH OF.

    So while we added 1 great arm, a couple decent arms, at least 1 good young 18yo A+ catcher, but added next to NOTHING for the lineup, while DESTROYING the pen, how does moving Varland...the original topic...do anything for the future of the franchise? 

    Maybe a couple years from now Roden is better than Wallner, Rodriguez, or Jenkins. Maybe Rojas is being undervalued and will be part of the future rotation, or a pen mainstay. Maybe Bradley makes us forget about Jax. But that's a handful "maybes" that would seem to have a MAJOR negative impact on 2026, and possibly 2027 as well.

    When you read reports from other teams how they "won" trades with the Twins, and don't see much in the way of positives for 2026, I really have to question Falvey at this point. It's almost as if they were making all these deals and just said "the hell with it. Let's make a few more"!

    Again, by itself, you can make arguements about the value of the return for Varland on an individual trade basis. But when you look at the OVERALL CONTEXT of these trades as a COLLECTIVE, you see a team with NO DIRECTION. 

    I suppose Ryan and/or Lopez will be next to HOPEFULLY add some BATS, and the complete teardown and re-build will commence. But considering where this team was less than 24 months ago, some quality prospects about ready to debut, it really didn't have to go down like this.

    Good trade.  Will miss Louie.  They don't make this trade unless they think they won it for their situation.  Varland will likely have ups and downs over his career, and his ups aren't necessary this year and next for sure for the Twins

    Both Varland and Stewart were traded for ifs. The Twins are addicted to ifs. We can spin and spin and spin to come up with ..... if Outman, if Rojas, if Roden. 

    The Dodgers and Blue Jays reached out to the Twins and saw guys who can, so they offered their ifs.

    17 hours ago, cjm0926 said:

    I don't think it is crazy to say at all that Louis Varland's value would possibly have been higher in the future. A year or two down the road if Varland kept improving like he already was showing he had been, with that nasty of stuff you could have been talking about a borderline Duran-esque return. With that being said, there are plenty of young players who show promise and eventually fade or regress. All in all, not a fan of the trade at all, but will cheer for Roden and Rojas' success, and will cheer extra hard for the sale of the team and the replacement of the front office and manager.

    Or Varland throwing 100 mph has tommy John soon.

    I admit I didn't like the trade because I liked that Varland was a Minnesota kid and I wanted to root for him on the Twins.  Having said that, Jays fans aren't happy with the trade, which does tell me something.

    Regarding us ending up with so many LH outfielders, I'm wondering if any of them are able to translate into a 1B?  If so, you might find your answer to why Rodan there.  Some of this may ultimately have to do with the unexpected retirement of Kiriloff.

    11 minutes ago, Richmond Dude said:

    I admit I didn't like the trade because I liked that Varland was a Minnesota kid and I wanted to root for him on the Twins.  Having said that, Jays fans aren't happy with the trade, which does tell me something.

    Regarding us ending up with so many LH outfielders, I'm wondering if any of them are able to translate into a 1B?  If so, you might find your answer to why Rodan there.  Some of this may ultimately have to do with the unexpected retirement of Kiriloff.

    Well, none of them have put on a 1B glove yet.......so I don't know. I mean, I'd consider it! But actions speak loudly, imo.

    I get that pedigree matters somehow, but Louis was about to be the closer. Trading him for a maybe starter and a maybe 4th outfielder feels a bit short for a guy that could close with 5 years of control. I don't care as much about being from MN or not. But, what he is/will be feel like it is worth more, or xould have been worth more this off-season. 




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...