???? Aaron Hicks became a 20/20 guy with a gold glove? holy $%#$ how long was i sleeping! lets be real man, his defense is barely above league average. His range is top 5 in the league, but his routes.. fangraphs will tell you how bad those are. At Yankee stadium id agree in hicks hitting 20 HRs someday but he will never have a WAR over 2 and our OF is packed with those kind of guys. Murphy is "NOT good" he's slightly above average defensively according to fangraphs and the bat isn't anything special you're right. He had a career .736 OPS in the minors, but even if that hangs close to .700 in the MLB he will be right around league average. whats wrong with giving up a 4th outfielder for a league average catcher? would you rather give up Berrios for 2 years of "Just above average but risky" in Lucroy because theres no way the Twins get him without giving up Sano/Buxton/Berrios/Kepler. for Christ sakes look how much Chris Herrmann just netted, a pretty good prospect