These are fair assessments in my view. I don't really think that he's the worst manager in the game, but he's clearly not the best. I think I'd grade him out in the C- range myself. Bullpen usage has always been an issue. Some of his lineups are odd at times, but that's not as big of a deal as other things. He caters to the veteran more than I'd like, which is a massive problem on a team that was young and up-and-coming when he was hired. He still exhibits this mentality now. While they have improved a bit over the course of the year, I still think that this team lacks sound fundamentals. I don't think he gets everything out of his players that he can. Baserunning and situational play, hallmarks of Molitor's playing career, are lacking on this team. If he can't instill his own strengths as a player into his team, that's a problem. I do think that he knows the game and knows it extremely well. I just don't think he's able to translate that into what it takes to be a good manager. He may be a very good coach in another situation, but I've never felt that he's been the right fit for this team.