Was Romero still an option for the playoff roster? Given how well our bullpen has been pitching, I can't imagine that Romero could have done anything to get himself on the playoff roster. I think it was a huge mistake putting him out there in our last game against our only competitors in the division -- a game we were winning! I also think it was not a good time to experiment with Gibson as a reliever. There is absolutely no reason to believe Gibson was up to the task, after his poor start on Thursday. Rather than screw around with his schedule, I'd have preferred to see the Twins try to get Gibson back on a normal schedule for starting, and have a short leash for him starting a playoff game (rather than just start the game off as a bullpen game, just prepare for the possibility when Gibson starts). Now, we may have screwed him up as a starter as well. And, most importantly, we could have won that game. Putting Romero and Gibson out there to protect a lead were not our best options for winning that game.