I think Seth has answered this adequately. As for discussing this issue, I don't think we need to analyze and pick apart every single at bat, every single pitch Joe does/does not swing at during ST. That is not discussion. Let's wait to see how ST goes first. All players use ST differently. It is there for them to ready themselves for the season, to try out new things, to hone a particular skill or to just find their in game routines again. While it would be great to see everyone get hits at every at bat, and yes, there is particular concern with Joe, let's just give the Joe issue a rest for now and see how ST goes.