I don't think he's looking for controversy, per se; I don't even think he meant much by it other than trying to joke around, and I think Serena took it as such as well. I pretty much rolled my eyes, and said 'Not this again.' I like McEnroe, a lot, as a tennis commentator and competitor; despite his antics he was a great tennis player, still is. The NPR commentary even concedes the physical differences between men and women athletes. I don't think the article is trying to force what McEnroe meant as much as just trying to use it as a springboard into the discussion of how do you compare the two and saying you can't. It's not that one is better than the other, or would win in a head to head contest, or would be ranked higher or lower if they would be playing against a different gender of competition. It goes to the heart of how men women athletes are characterized. 'Plays like a guy' or 'Plays like a girl' have connotations that I think should be retired. I hear that on here quite frequently in the more commonly phrased 'Throws like a girl' and various other things. No one actually thinks about what that means and just throws that out there as if that's an acceptable characterization. Comparing men and women athletes ... you just can't do it, so why even say things like that? I think because we are just conditioned to it. Women athletes aren't good because 'they play like a guy,' they are good because they are good. Period. Serena is one of the best tennis players, ever, male or female, not because she could play and destroy in men's tennis, because I'm not sure she could, I don't know if she could, it's really a different game. You can't compare them like that. She's one of the best ever, male or female, because of how she goes about her game, how she plays it. Same with the woman basketball player mentioned. Same with any pro female athlete. They are good because they are. Period. As I said, I still hear this so often ... 'She's pretty good, for a girl' ... 'She's good because she plays like a man.' Those are just stupid and pointless comments.