Like I mentioned in my previous post, I'm not ignoring information. I'm well aware of the scouting reports for all the players we are discussing. Hu is a low ceiling/ high floor pitcher with good command, above average potentially plus fastball that lacks a true K pitch. He has the potential to be a #3, but more likely a #4/5. FWIW, Seth always said Hu has the potential of #3. Nothing in his statistical performance has lead me to believe otherwise. Where we disagree is Stewart- I think when statistical history over multiple seasons over multiple levels of minor league ball all contradict the scouting report- doubting or discounting scouting reports is justifiable, humans after all are fallible.