I like to zig when everyone else is zagging. Think that's why the Rays are where they are. We could do something very similar with our pitching staff. Here is my off-season take (feel free to laugh!). I do like the idea of Grandal catching and Garver playing primarily 1B, but I'm guessing Milwaukee picks up his option. Instead, I want to sign Castellanos and have him play 1B/part time OF/part time DH. If you can play 3B, you should be able to play 1B. He is going to be expensive. He will be worth it. He is going to be cheaper than Abreu, and 5 years younger. He will be in his prime during our "window." Though Cron did a nice job for us this year, but no mas. Nicolas Castellanos 5 years/125 million with opt out after year 2 I'm not huge on Castro as a backup, but not many options as a bridge to our farm boys. He is familiar with our staff, which puts him slightly ahead of a few other FA catchers. Jason Castro 1 year/3 million Sano stays at third. Polanco stays at SS. Arraez 2B, Marwin/Gordon/Ehire UTIL. Cruz DH. Keeping our outfield in tact as well. Rosario/Buxton/Kepler. Roll the dice and extend Buxton 5 years/40 million. Here's where we get a little funky. Madison Bumgarner 3 years/50 million Will Smith 3 years/40 million Dellin Betances 2 years/10 million Tony Cingrani 2 years/10 million Berrios is our lone "full-time starter." Bumgarner, Smeltzer, Dobnak are part time starters/part time secondary pitchers. Betances, Cingrani, and Graterol are openers/middle pen guys. Rogers, Duffey, May and Stashak back-end guys. AAA and AA guys audition for final spot(s).