Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Lonestar

Verified Member
  • Posts

    493
  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Lonestar

  1. There's a difference between drafting someone who you think can be the biggest star in the draft and someone who you think will be the biggest star. Hunter Green CAN BE the biggest star in this draft. If he develops more movement on his fastball while retaining velocity. And if he develops two other plus pitches. You could make a case that Gore, Baz, and Carlson are better pitching prospects now. And they would be better prospects still if they had 3 years experience in the SEC. Of course that would make them Kyle Wright. If they were flashing 4 plus pitches.
  2. Many get distracted by the fact that McKay is currently a two-way player. One thing they get distracted from is what he could become as a pitcher if that was all he focused on. Operative words = "could become".
  3. As far as that goes, I think there is a different between dominant and dominating. 7 IP, 0 ER, 2 H, 11 K is a dominating performance but Scott Diamond or Aaron Slegers could do that on occasion. Berrios' 39 IP, 5 ER, 39K, 8 BB, .807 WHIP is dominant But Gonzalves' start is encouraging. Any word on his velocity
  4. I don't think Randy Rosario is getting enough attention. He's already on the 40-man roster and could be the first LH reliever called up, especially because his splits are nearly identical.
  5. There's a difference between throws the hardest and highest ceiling. FWIW, Jordon Adell might have the highest ceiling. There's also something to be said for highest expected value. Some would say that's McKay. I give the edge to Wright because of his perceived ceiling and relative margin for error (velocity). Some speculate that McKay could be MLB ready this year -- in time for a playoff push. Wright might be ready after next year's Super 2 deadline.
  6. I looked up Wright's last 5 starts and compared them to McKay's in the same time period. SSS but not necessarily cherry picking ERA 1.14 | 1.26 BB% 5.11% | 9.43% SO% 37.23% | 33.02% G0/FO 1.78 | 0.77 Wright had slightly stronger competition. We know there's more to command and control than BB% and SO%. McKay had one 5-inning start without his best stuff. He also missed a start for reason unknown to me. He was experimenting with a new cutter. Some would give the edge to McKay because he is an LHP. Some wouldn't draft a LHB 1B at 1-1 because Target Field is hard on LH power. That same reasoning would apply to LHP's. I don't get either. That is, the Twins are going to need some left handedness. Left handedness could be a tie breaker if they were tied. I think Wright is the better pitching prospect.
  7. I'm surprised no one has commented on this: http://www.1500espn.com/twins-2/2017/05/twins-draft-brendan-mckay-first-overall-pitcher-hitter/
  8. So what are the possibilities of Carlson playing up his Florida commitment, then signing for 1-15 money ($3,588,200) at #35.
  9. That's true. It's also true that Taillon was born in Canada. But he pitched high school ball for The Woodlands in Texas.
  10. FWIW, I didn't say give him an ultimatum. Buxton seems to have a fragile psyche andultimatums would likely be bad for that psyche. But I wouldn't let him flounder for 3 months either. That would be worse for his psyche. He rebooted in Rochester last year and did fine. The second time.
  11. I agree there is nothing left to prove there. And I'm certainly not giving up on him. But Buxton needs to reboot. If he can't reboot here, let him try in Rochester. I would give him until the end of the month.
  12. Jay had a high ceiling and still has a high floor -- much higher than the expected value 1-6 picks. Jay was a multi-inning shutdown reliever in college because that was his coach's choice to maximize his value in more than 1 game a week. I liked Benintendi and Happ before the draft but personally picked Jay. How many of us would have howled if the Twins would have drafted Benintendi with Rosario, Buxton, and Kepler in route and a shortage of frontline starters.
  13. Why are we signing up for a free newsletter? I could understand if it was behind a pay wall. And why can't we read old newsletters?
  14. Remember when the Mets took Dwight Gooden at 1-5.
  15. Park was not the reason Sano was relegated to RF. Plouffe was. The Twins are bound and determined to play Sano in the field. I can't find the quote, but Falvine or Molly reserved the right to play Sano in RF. Park and Vargas are not redundant. I think the Twins want a regular DH. Both have MiLB options. Both can play in Rochester if necessary. Neither is the 40th man on the roster. Danny Santana is. So this is either a way of saving Pohlad money. Or it's an attempt to free up a spot on the 40 man roster. In either case I think they chose poorly.
  16. The only long reliever candidates mentioned are Haley, Duffy, and Hughes. Gotta have long reliever. Unless someone gets hurt in spring training, Kintzler, Belisle, Chargois, and Pressly are locks as are Boshers and Rogers. Tonkins is the odd man out. In a rebuilding year, I would rather take a chance on fixing Tonkin's hard contact than hoping Belisle is serviceable and maybe flippable. And Tonkin's trouble is not a straight fastball. He throws only 4-seamers that Brooks classifies as 2-seamers. Of course I've been rooting for Tonkin for years.
  17. IIRC, the Twins were going to slightly reduce payroll in 2017. That would lower Falvine's flexibility for certain initiatives - especially while they were waiting for the Dozier trade resolution and then ending up with his salary.
  18. It's more fun playing that game when you aren't "most people". If he's not in the top 3, disappointed is fair. Twins have lousy history at SS.
  19. Except for the part that Toles bats left handed and cant hit LHPs
  20. I planned on no innings from Hughes in 2017. If he is capable of more than pitching batting practice, I would put him in long relief/swing man. If he is capable of high leverage relief, I think he would also be a good starting pitcher and that's where I would put him. My $.02. If Hughes is starting, I don't see the Twins starting all four vets -- Santana, Gibson, Santiago, and Hughes. I think Santiago would be the odd man out.
  21. It is true that 2014 was an outlier season. Is it true that the Twins paid him for it? Hughes put up 5.9 WAR. The Twins increased his pay from $8M to $13.5M. That's less than 2 WAR. Hughes' extensions exposed the Twins to more risk of injury. Then again, he got hurt during the pre-extension years. We all expected Hughes to regress after 2014. 2014 could still have been a break through. How many of us expected him to regress from 5.9 WAR to less than 2? He put up 2.6 as a starter in 2010 and 2.4 in 2012. If TOS is the special cause of his regression, we don't know how much of an outlier his 2014 is/was. And we might not ever know.
  22. I don't understand why some curse extending Hughes. No one mentions not trading Hughes after 2014 when his value was highest, but if the Twins were not going to trade him, his extension looks like a good deal. I agree with this Fangraphs pundit who wrote this in the midst of Hughes struggles in 2015: That writer blamed a slippage in Hughes' command. That was evidently before Hughes lost almost 2 MPH on the fastball. Both problems could be attributable to Thoracic Outlet Syndrome. We'll have to see if surgery and rehab fix the problem. If they do fix the problem, I'm not expecting Hughes to return to his 2014 form but he could be better than his Yankee incarnation -- more like 2-3 Wins.
×
×
  • Create New...