A normal Mauer is a run creator. But he doesn't do it in the ways everyone can easily point to like the HR. But he creates them, His OBP has value in the TEAM scoring runs. His ability to put bat on ball a lot and move runners over, is valuable. You would surely get more HR from the others, but you'd also lose like 60 points or so in OBP and 50 or so in BA and add Ks and so on. And lose on D too. The HRs would look pretty, but there is more to creating runs than that. So, now, until these guys prove they can score a wRC+ in the 130s-150s, I still believe that a regular Mauer will help our offense more because we'll have more opps to score runs based on his skills. Having said that, I think it'd be best for Mauer to waive his no trade and let the Twins move him if they actually want to.