About your list, it's a list that promotes good discussion. Few thoughts on it: I don't think Bumgardner is a shoo-in at all, he's a quality pitcher, and he had a legendary W Series performance in 2014, but he doesn't have a CY nor has he been in top 3 in voting, He's never led the league in ERA, Ks, IP, ERA+, Wins, Etc. All the things that get looked at, whether I agree with all of that or not. If Mussina can't get in (and he likely won't though he should) I doubt Bums deserves it. I think Weaver has zero chance. I think Trout will definitely get in unless he just crashes and burns, which I can't see happening. I think Molina will definitely make it. If you value defense (both throwing guys out and calling a game), he's likely a top 5 catcher ever. He's the Ozzie Smith of catchers. I think Mauer should for what he accomplished as a catcher, but he likely won't now due to his drop-off unless he can come back strong. ARod and Braun likely won't due to PED stuff and in ARod's case, one can add the media dislike for him as well. Stanton will very likely make it unless he just drops off a cliff. His talent is too strong. Tulo won't due to the Coors Field bias.