I'm sorry, it doesn't. The problem you have is that there are plenty of vaccinations being required that aren't. Chicken pox is a real good example. I've had it. You've probably had it. It's not dangerous, except in adults which is really just shingles and not typically deadly either, just very unpleasant. As an adult, go ahead and get the vaccine by choice, but force on a child that doesn't need it? Not to mention that there are side effects here, ones which the pharmaceutical industry also profits off of. This policy opens a door, and one where a lot of non-necessary vaccines with very real side effects get forced on people with the real purpose of making a buck... all in the name of the greater good. In the mean time you have entire groups of people who have chosen not to do any vaccines such as the Amish. I suppose they just need to be wiped off the face of the earth as Dave has suggested, yet at the same time, their children aren't being ravished by these diseases. To be clear, I'm not anti-vaccine. I am, however, rather pragmatic about assuming unnecessary risk. I've vaccinated my children against polio, mmr, etc. But at the end of the day, I shouldn't have to fight society over something like chickenpox or other non-essential vaccines. It's a choice that me and my doctor need to make. No one else.