No, he's pointing out an example of how just because something works doesn't make it the right decision. That's a logical fallacy, and he's giving an example of how/why ....
He hit the same in the leadoff spot (after a hot start) as he did before they put him there.
The foot is clearly an issue batting.....I'd like to see them rest him and put Lewis at SS and ? at third. But I get why they aren't resting him. I don't get not moving him down in the order, though.
In the meantime, he's an auto out. Just wasting at bats. Also, they better not make a claim. As you point out, they have Buxton, AK and Castro coming back (and Martin and Stevenson in AAA).
This. They can't claim and drop immediately, which they'll do when Buxton, Castro, AK are back on the OFers.....Also, Martin is right there.....I have no idea why anyone wants to claim mediocre OFs right now.