Using the baseball-reference calculation of WAR, there are three Blue Jay finalists with negative WAR (Kirk, Springer, and Jesus Sanchez), two more with WAR less than 1 (Vladdy Jr and Gimenez) and the overall vote leader that gets a starting spot automatically with WAR of exactly 1.0 (Ernie Clement)
For reference, Kirk and Sanchez have the same WAR as Tristan Gray, who is not an All-Star finalist
Could you imagine if they ever tried to put actual tangible meaning on the All-Star Game by, say, awarding homefield advantage in the World Series based on its result? Wouldn't that be insanely stupid? Good thing they'd never go and do something like that