“What really helped [Billy Beane] was his ability & courage to think out of the (old school) box, using analytics to come out ahead in trades. IMO, now, the pendulum has swung far to the other side, where analytics drives the sport & "in the box" thinking is analytics.”
There’s the problem explained in two sentences. Everyone wanted to be Billy Beane and embrace the numbers, while cutting back on scouting staffs. Looking at potential is great. But without guys who are proven judges of a players’ abilities (and weaknesses) on the field, well, we’re seeing the results.
What we need now is someone who has the ability and courage to combine some of that old-school approach. But that’s going to also require more scouts scouring the countryside for talent that the numbers alone may not show.
Great article.