This is the part of being a fan I am most fascinated with: trying to be the GM without knowing all of the knowledge the GM knows in how to plan an organization for the next 1-5 years. There are many things that concern me regarding this list or anyone that still has years left of arbitration left before free agency.
The team is still for sale at this moment, and I would find it frightening that a FO that may not be there would make sweeping changes that will affect the team for years to come. I don't see many of our players with years left of arbitration that have enough built-up value to bring back any value in a trade that would help us in the near future. Additionally, there is an expected lockout after the 2026 season. The first potential work stoppage that will include the minor league players, as they are now part of the players union. Any prolonged work stoppage may affect the minor leagues as well. Think of another COVID type year and how that affected development of the minor leaguers.
The players:
Duran or Jax - I think we are fooling ourselves into thinking we are going to get a crop full of prospects for either one of them. I also look at the Josh Hader trade from Milwaukee to San Diego. Hader was traded a year later than a potential Duran trade, but was more well-established as a dominant closer, and yet still fell quite short of the kind of package we are expecting from a Duran trade. If we believe in this core, then you believe in a re-tooling for next year and Duran for next year is more valuable to you than what you would likely receive in a trade.
Larnach or Wallner - Larnach is a year closer to free agency and that always factors in your decision. I don't see either one as really a strong enough trade piece to generate a useful prospect at the deadline. This decision is better made for the offseason.
Lewis - I'm not as worried as Lewis turning into the next David Ortiz as I am just making sure he is healthy, and we know everything we can get out of him prior to making a decision. This may include seeing if he is willing to pick up a first baseman's glove in the offseason, especially if you believe in Keaschall coming back and being able to plug into 2B. Lewis may end up being closer to Gio Urshela or Glyber Torres than Nolan Arenado, but we really won't know that until we have a full season where he is not injured for most of it.
We also have questions about Julien, Miranda, Martin, and others where they fit in the system going forward. I'll end with this. The Royals have brought up Jac Caglianone and seem to be committed to playing him on a daily basis, although he currently has an OPS+ of 21. Do you think the Twins would do the same with Walker Jenkins or Emmy Rodriguez?