The problem is we are seeing the shooting as a punishment and not an incident, and because we see it as a punishment we leap to things like murder. If we start from the point that this probably is not murder, but it is really bad and needs to be prevented as much as possibly with reasonable criminal charges to the officer in a case like this. The trial because it was about murder did not need to determine if the shooting was justified or not it just came down to what the murder law actually is. Clearly we mostly agree a mistake even a really bad one like this may have been or like a DWI related death is not murder. Now I'm not going to say there is no chance this guy or other officers haven't decided if they get a borderline case they won't hesitate to shoot a black man, and that would truly be murder, but unless they've told another person those intentions it's unprovable.