You seem to have forgotten some things. Mastroianni's Spring training was about as productive as Hicks, save for that one, monster game Hicks had (3HRs plus at least another hit or maybe a walk). Hicks was hitting HRs that Spring, Mastroianni had about the same BAVG--but not the HRs. Then, Mastroianni's injury--he wasn't the same afterwards--a sad tale. But his Spring Training was very productive--normally enough to win the starter's job, except for Hick's HRs (plus Hicks had the halo effect of a 1st round draft choice). Things would not have been so bad in 2013 if Mastroianni had not been injured given the Hicks failure.