At this point, you have to look at any trade as a rebuild move, and not as a playoff push move. Exactly 1 of 28 teams to start 0-8 finished >.500, and none made the playoffs. The Twins dug a hole that they mostly likely won't get out of until Apr 2017. So trading Plouffe to improve the 2016 defense would be a pointless goal. With that in mind, give PT to the guys who are causing the bottleneck- Arcia, Plouffe, Park, etc in hopes of building their stock. Re-balance this July/winter for fair returns. The worst thing would be to squander good assets, and Plouffe is one, under the delusion that improving the defense could make or break their playoff chances in 2016. Because it probably won't matter.